Home |  About MLP |  Welcoming Churches |  Movement Events |  MLP Resources |  Donate to MLP | 

Home > General News

San Francisco Presbytery: equality and un-tenet-able proposals both up for consideration

  View Printable Version 
Wednesday, August 30 2006 @ 06:15 PM
Rev. Will McGarvey of Community Presbyterian Church in Pittsburgh, California has noted two very different proposals coming to San Francisco Presbytery in September - one brought by LGBT equality supporters; the other is the "un-tenet-able" 980-essentials proposal brought by Presbyterian Coalition supporters. In response, the Presbytery is considering convening a task force to study the proposals.


Offered by the session of Noe Valley Ministries:

Covenant Faithfulness

The Session of Noe Valley Ministries moves that the Presbytery of San Francisco offer the following statement of Covenant Faithfulness to any Task Force that shall be established to prepare guidance for the Presbytery in determining the implementation of Ordination standards, or to affirm if no such Task Force is established.

“As God has called each of us to covenant faithfulness through Christ, we as the Presbytery of San Francisco seek to live as faithful disciples of Christ in every part of our lives. Our Constitution calls us to a new openness to the presence of God in the Church and in the world, to a new openness to its own membership by affirming itself as a community of diversity, and to the possibilities and perils of its institutional forms in order to ensure the faithfulness and usefulness of these forms to Gods activity in the world (G-3.0401a-c).

To these ends, we invite the Presbytery to affirm God’s love and presence in all of God’s children. We invite the Presbytery to consider the cost to the Body of Christ when whole groups of people in the church are pressured to be dishonest about themselves or those whom they love. We invite the Presbytery to consider how its policies exclude sexual minorities from serving Christ through the ordained ministries of the Church. We invite the Presbytery to recognize that Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Christians can live lives of covenant faithfulness with their life partners or in singleness, and therefore, that such Christians may be found eligible to serve God and the Church through the offices of Deacon, Elder and Minister of Word and Sacrament. Thus, it shall be the policy of the Presbytery's Committee on Preparation for Ministry and its Committee on Ministry, in keeping with the Authoritative Interpretation of G-6.0108 passed by the 217th General Assembly, not to discriminate against any candidate based solely on their marital status, sexual orientation or gender identity, but to discern God’s calling in every candidate's life based on their preparation and qualifications to serve God and the Church as Minister of Word and Sacrament.”



First Presbyterian Church of Concord, on the other hand, has submitted this proposal, which is derived from language recently recommended by the Presbyterian Coalition, an anti-LGBT organization:

"For the sake of the peace, unity, and purity of the church, San Francisco Presbytery adopts and functions according to the following principle: it is an essential of Reformed polity that San Francisco Presbytery comply with and adhere to the standards for ordination adopted by the whole church and expressed in the Book of Order. Therefore, any departure from ordination standards mandated* in the Book of Order shall bar a candidate from ordination and/or installation by San Francisco Presbytery.
[*"ordination standards mandated in the Book of Order" include those instructions designated by the terms "shall," "is/are to be, " "requirement" or equivalent.]”



As of mid-August, this notice appeared on the Presbytery of San Francisco's web site:

To ministers and congregations of the Presbytery of San Francisco:

We are aware that members of our church are concerned about recommendations from the Peace, Unity and Purity report passed this summer by our General Assembly. Presbytery Council will be considering our presbytery's need to talk about and determine action related to standards for ordination.

Specifically, Council is considering naming a task force to guide our presbytery in our work on this matter and would bring a report about creating such a task force to the September meeting of Presbytery. Members could include persons from COM, CPM and others and would represent the diverse concerns on this matter.

We write now to let you know that the Presbytery Council convenes on Wednesday, Aug. 23, 2006, to consider this and other items on our docket.

Coveting the Holy Spirit's wisdom as we discern Christ's mind on this matter, we ask that you join in prayer for the members of Council to hear God's voice as we meet and pray and work together. We invite you to share this prayer request with congregations as you gather for worship this coming weekend.

May Christ's peace be with you!

Rev. Linda Regan
Chair of Presbytery Council

Elder Jack Johnson
Moderator of the Presbytery of San Francisco



Bookmark and Share
What's Related

Story Options


Editor sign-in.   Created this page in 1.09 seconds

Website developed by ReachAndTeach.com and More Light Presbyterians.
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.